Which has the higher profit split: Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

TradeDay pays the higher profit split at 95%, compared to Blue Guardian's 90%. The split applies to verified payouts after the funded stage and KYC.

Which firm allows larger funded accounts: Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian allows larger funded allocations, with accounts up to $2,000,000. TradeDay caps allocations at $150,000.

What platforms does Blue Guardian support compared to TradeDay?

Blue Guardian supports MT5, MatchTrader, TradeLocker, while TradeDay supports Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView. Platform availability depends on the program tier purchased and the asset class (forex vs futures).

Which firm should I choose: Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Choose Blue Guardian if you prioritize 90% profit split, $2,000,000 max allocation, and Gros-Islet, St. Lucia jurisdiction. Choose TradeDay if you prioritize 95% profit split, $150,000 max allocation, and Chicago, Illinois, United States jurisdiction. Both have been tested by PropFirm Key with documented funded payouts.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Blue Guardian vs TradeDay: Which Is Better in 2026?

Q: Which is cheaper: Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian is the cheaper option, with entry-level evaluations starting at $27. TradeDay starts at $125. Both firms charge a one-time evaluation fee with reset costs separate.

Compare Blue Guardian and TradeDay side by side. Profit splits, prices, challenges, payout speed, trading rules, and more. Based on verified data.

Bottom line: Blue Guardian offers up to $2,000,000 with a 90% profit split, while TradeDay offers up to $150,000 at 95%. Cheapest entry: $27 (Blue Guardian). Editorial scores on PropFirm Key: 3.8/5 (Blue Guardian) vs 4.9/5 (TradeDay).

Last updated: July 3, 2026

Quick Verdict

Overall Winner

TradeDay

Scores 85/100 overall based on trust, conditions, payouts, strategies, and platform access.

/ 100

Rating

3.8

4.9

Blue GuardianTradeDay

Profit Split

90%

95%

Blue GuardianTradeDay

Starting Price

$27

$125

Blue GuardianTradeDay

Max Allocation

$2M

$150K

Blue GuardianTradeDay

First Payout

14 days

1 days

Blue GuardianTradeDay

Strategy Freedom

5/8

3/8

Blue GuardianTradeDay

Score Breakdown

Blue Guardian

Trust & Reputation

Trading Conditions

Payout Quality

Strategy Freedom

Platform & Access

TradeDay

Trust & Reputation

Trading Conditions

Payout Quality

Strategy Freedom

Platform & Access

100

Detailed Side-by-Side Comparison

Metric

Blue Guardian

TradeDay

Overview

Rating

3.8

4.9

Reviews

2,028

1,331

Years Active

7 years

6 years

Verified

Country

Market

forex

futures

Pricing & Value

Starting Price

$27

$125

Max Allocation

$2M

$150K

Profit Split

90%

95%

Fee Refundable

Best Discount

50% off

30% off

Risk Management

Daily Loss Limit

$2,000

Max Loss

10%

$3,000

Drawdown Type

static

trailing

Leverage

1:50

N/A

Execution

STP

ECN

Payouts

First Payout

14 days

1 days

Payout Frequency

bi-weekly

on-demand

Scaling

Allowed Strategies

EA/Bots

Scalping

News Trading

Weekend Hold

Copy Trading

Hedging

Martingale

HFT

Platforms & Access

Platforms

MT5, MatchTrader, TradeLocker

Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, TradeDayX, Quantower, ATAS, Jigsaw

Assets

FX, Metals, Indices, Commodities, Crypto

ES, NQ, YM, RTY, CL, GC, SI, ZB, ZN, 6E, 6J

US Accepted

View Blue Guardian

View TradeDay

Challenge Price Comparison

Comparing prices for matching account sizes available at both Blue Guardian and TradeDay.

Account Size

Blue Guardian

TradeDay

Savings

$50K(3-step)

$114

$88

Save $26 with TradeDay

$100K(3-step)

$184

$140

Save $44 with TradeDay

Pros & Cons

Blue Guardian

Pros

Higher max allocation ($2M)
Lower starting price ($27)
Refundable challenge fee
More trading strategies allowed (5/8)
More reviews (2,028)

Cons

Lower rating than TradeDay
Lower profit split (90% vs 95%)
Slower first payout (14 days)
US traders not accepted

TradeDay

Pros

Higher rating (4.9/5 vs 3.8/5)
Better profit split (95% vs 90%)
Faster first payout (1 days)
Accepts US traders

Cons

Higher starting price ($125)
Challenge fee not refundable
Fewer allowed strategies

Who Should Choose Which?

Choose Blue Guardian if you...

Are looking for a budget-friendly option
Need high capital allocation (up to $2M)
Plan to scale your account over time
Need maximum trading flexibility (EAs, scalping, news trading)
Want your challenge fee refunded after passing

View Blue Guardian Details

Choose TradeDay if you...

Want the highest possible profit split
Want fast payouts
Plan to scale your account over time
Are a US-based trader
Prioritize a highly-rated, trusted firm

View TradeDay Details

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Blue Guardian better than TradeDay?

Based on our data-driven analysis, TradeDay scores 85/100 overall. Blue Guardian excels in strategy freedom, while TradeDay stands out for payout quality. The best choice depends on your priorities as a trader.

Which is cheaper, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian starts at $27 while TradeDay starts at $125. Blue Guardian offers the lower entry price. However, consider the profit split and payout rules for the true value comparison.

Which has better profit splits, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian offers up to 90% profit split, while TradeDay offers up to 95% profit split. TradeDay has the higher profit share. Some firms increase splits through scaling programs.

Can I use Expert Advisors (EAs) with Blue Guardian and TradeDay?

Blue Guardian allows Expert Advisors, and TradeDay allows them. Both firms support automated trading.

Which firm pays out faster, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?

Blue Guardian's first payout is available after 14 days with bi-weekly frequency. TradeDay offers first payout after 1 days with on-demand payouts. TradeDay gets you paid sooner.

Are Blue Guardian and TradeDay legit?

Blue Guardian has been operating for 7 years with 2,028 reviews and a 3.8/5 ratingverified. TradeDay has 6 years of operation with 1,331 reviews and a 4.9/5 ratingverified. Both are established prop trading firms.